The stars of the hit dark comedy A Simple Favor are back. Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick return in the highly anticipated sequel, Another Simple Favor, set to premiere on Prime Video on May 1, 2025. The new film follows the unpredictable friendship between two women — and this time, it all unravels at a wild wedding in Italy.
The story continues the journey of Stephanie (Anna Kendrick), a suburban mom-turned-sleuth, and her mysterious frenemy, Emily (Blake Lively). After surviving lies, secrets, and even a double murder in the first film, the two find themselves tangled up again — only now, Emily is getting married.
Emily’s Italian Wedding Turns Chaotic
Set against the scenic backdrop of Italy, Another Simple Favor begins with Emily’s surprise return to high society. Though she was convicted of murder in the first film, trailers for the sequel show her living a glamorous life, free from prison.
Now planning a lavish destination wedding, Emily invites the last person you’d expect — Stephanie — to be her maid of honor.
In a first-look photo shared during Collider’s exclusive summer preview, viewers catch a glimpse of the drama to come. Emily clutches Stephanie while chaos erupts off-camera. Stephanie’s shocked expression says it all, hinting that trouble is never far behind the bride.
What Happened in the First Film?
In A Simple Favor (2018), directed by Paul Feig (Bridesmaids), viewers met Stephanie, a single mom and vlogger who gets drawn into Emily’s dark, glamorous world. When Emily mysteriously vanishes, Stephanie uncovers a web of secrets involving faked deaths, insurance fraud, and murder.
By the film’s end, Emily is arrested for killing her twin sister and former husband. Stephanie, meanwhile, starts a new life as a private investigator. The movie earned strong reviews for its sharp humor, unexpected plot twists, and the electric chemistry between its leads.
From Convicted Killer to Blushing Bride
One of the biggest mysteries in Another Simple Favor is how Emily managed to get out of jail. The film doesn’t reveal the full story upfront, but viewers know she’s free, wealthy again, and planning a wedding.
Her invitation to Stephanie raises eyebrows. Why would Stephanie, who helped send Emily to prison, agree to help her plan a wedding? That’s one of the film’s main questions — and likely one of its biggest traps.
As Paul Feig told Collider, “This film pushes things even further. Just when you think you know where it’s going, we flip the script again.”
Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick Return to Their Iconic Roles
Blake Lively once again plays the confident and mysterious Emily. Known for her bold fashion choices in the first film, Emily’s wedding dress in the sequel doesn’t disappoint. The white gown with a dramatic red hem adds to the tension — a nod to her deadly reputation.
Anna Kendrick returns as the quirky yet clever Stephanie. While she has grown since the first movie, her decision to fly across the world for Emily shows she might still be caught in her frenemy’s web.
Their dynamic drives the story, with sharp dialogue and plenty of suspense.
Paul Feig Expands the Stylish Thriller Universe
Director Paul Feig, known for mixing comedy and mystery, returns for Another Simple Favor. He described the sequel as “bolder, darker, and funnier,” promising even more stylish thrills and shocking turns.
Feig reunites with screenwriter Jessica Sharzer for the sequel. The pair have hinted that the film dives deeper into both women’s pasts while exploring loyalty, betrayal, and reinvention.
“It’s about how far you’re willing to go for someone you can’t trust,” Feig said.
Prime Video Release and What to Expect
Another Simple Favor will be available exclusively on Prime Video starting May 1, 2025. With the first movie becoming a cult hit, expectations are high for the sequel.
Fans can expect:
-
A mix of humor, mystery, and stylish drama
-
A plot full of unexpected twists
-
A deeper look into Emily and Stephanie’s love-hate friendship
-
A glamorous but deadly destination wedding
Whether you’re new to the series or a longtime fan, the sequel promises to deliver another unforgettable ride.
