Alma Metals, a mineral exploration company listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX), has seen its shares rise 25% over the past week. While this sharp rebound has helped reduce insider losses, they remain deep in the red. Company insiders had collectively invested AU$386,500 in company shares during the past 12 months. However, their holdings are still down by around AU$142,000 based on the current share price of AU$0.005.
This situation highlights a common concern for investors: whether insider buying is always a good signal to follow.
Insider Buying: A Risk That Has Yet to Reward
Insider purchases often suggest confidence in a company’s future, but they don’t always lead to immediate gains. One of the largest single insider transactions at Alma Metals came from Executive Chairman Alasdair Cooke. He bought AU$200,000 worth of shares at AU$0.008 each — a price that now looks overly optimistic.
Today, Alma’s shares trade at AU$0.005, meaning that Cooke and other insiders are holding their shares at a paper loss. Even with this week’s bounce in price, the gap between their purchase prices and current valuations remains significant.
Insider Transactions in the Past Year
In total, insiders acquired about 48.81 million shares for approximately AU$386,000. During the same period, they sold just 668,660 shares for a modest AU$6,000. This shows a net increase in insider ownership over the past year — a sign that insiders still believe in the company’s long-term potential.
The lack of selling, even as share prices dropped in earlier months, may point to long-term confidence. Still, the timing of these purchases suggests they may have been premature.
Insider Ownership: How Much Skin Do They Have in the Game?
Insiders currently hold around 15% of Alma Metals, representing approximately AU$1.2 million in value. While that’s a decent chunk of the company, it’s not considered particularly high by market standards.
Some of this ownership might be indirect — held through trusts or private entities — making the true stake a bit less transparent. But even so, a 15% insider stake does signal some alignment between management and shareholder interests.
Why Insider Transactions Matter
While investors shouldn’t base their entire strategy on insider trades, these actions often provide useful insights. Buying shares at a price higher than the current one shows past confidence from company executives. However, share prices can fall for many reasons, such as weak earnings, poor market conditions, or unfavorable commodity prices — all relevant risks in the mining and exploration sector.
Experts advise combining insider data with broader company fundamentals. As analyst Sarah Tan from Equity Advisory Group notes:“Insider buying is a great starting point for deeper research, but not a standalone signal. Look at the company’s cash flow, debt levels, and exploration pipeline.”
No Recent Insider Activity in Latest Quarter
Interestingly, there haven’t been any insider transactions reported in the most recent quarter. This might reflect caution or simply a holding pattern, as insiders wait to see if the stock stabilizes or rebounds further.
Alma Metals’ Challenges Ahead
While the insider buying trend is encouraging, Alma Metals still faces several challenges. According to analysts, the company is exposed to:
-
Commodity price volatility
-
High exploration costs
-
Project development delays
-
Lack of near-term cash flow
In fact, five warning signs have been flagged for Alma Metals, four of which are considered serious risks. These include funding concerns and uncertain drilling outcomes.
For investors, this means caution is warranted — even if insiders are still holding their positions.
Alma Metals’ recent share price rise may offer some short-term relief to insiders, but their long-term bet remains underwater. With insider purchases still showing a loss, it’s clear that buying into optimism hasn’t paid off yet. Still, the commitment of executives — especially the large purchase by Alasdair Cooke — shows they’re in it for the long haul.
