Fifty years after Earth Day 1970, Kathleen Bethel, a long-time observer of U.S. politics, reflects on how the nation’s political landscape and values have evolved. In an open letter directed at current U.S. senators and congressmen, Bethel contrasts the ideals of her youth with today’s political realities, calling for introspection and action. The piece touches on issues ranging from climate change and civil rights to reproductive rights and public education, urging lawmakers to reconsider their stance on key social matters.
A Time of Hope and Change
In 1970, Earth Day marked a pivotal moment for environmental awareness. At that time, young activists were united by a shared goal: to protect the planet from industrial pollution. Bethel recalls marching alongside political figures who, back then, seemed committed to fighting for a cleaner, more sustainable future. Today, however, she finds it disheartening to see many of those same leaders dismiss climate change as a non-issue. The stark contrast in attitudes prompts Bethel to ask: “How did we arrive here?”
The Transformation of Political Ideals
Looking back, Bethel highlights the difference in attitudes towards social issues. In the past, public figures seemed to embrace progressive causes, such as civil rights and gender equality. Today, however, she argues that many of the same individuals who once advocated for freedom and equality are now pushing for policies that restrict transgender rights and women’s reproductive choices. Bethel points out the irony in this shift, especially when many of the same leaders once championed the fight for equality and inclusiveness.
Reproductive Rights: A Matter of Personal Responsibility
Bethel addresses the evolving conversation around reproductive rights, particularly the importance of access to abortion. She reminds lawmakers of their past actions and decisions, pointing out how their past political behavior—including their personal relationships—may not align with their current stance on reproductive health. In her view, pushing for restrictions on women’s autonomy over their own bodies reflects a profound disconnect between political rhetoric and the lived realities of women across the country.
Immigration: A Changing Narrative
Bethel turns her attention to the subject of immigration. She recalls how, during the earlier part of her life, the American identity was shaped by the stories of immigrants who came to the U.S. seeking a better future. Now, she argues, there’s a stark contrast in the way immigrants are viewed and treated. Lawmakers who once recognized the value of immigration as a force for progress now seem determined to create barriers for those seeking refuge or opportunity in the U.S.
The Legacy of Civil Rights and Education
In the 1960s and 1970s, social justice was a central theme in American politics, and many lawmakers were active in supporting civil rights causes. Bethel recalls the influence of figures like Cesar Chavez, John F. Kennedy, and Martin Luther King Jr. Yet, as she observes today, many leaders who once championed equality now support policies that undermine the very programs designed to uplift marginalized communities. Bethel highlights the reduction in funding for education, nutrition, and healthcare, all of which disproportionately affect those who need help the most.
Public Lands and the Environment: Protecting the Future
Bethel also reflects on the nation’s past commitment to preserving its natural resources. In her youth, environmental conservation was a key priority, with national parks and endangered species protection receiving significant attention. Today, she is alarmed by the ongoing trend of selling off public lands for private profit, undermining future generations’ ability to experience and protect the country’s natural beauty.
The Vietnam War and Political Division
The Vietnam War divided the nation, with many young people protesting the conflict while others enlisted in the military. Bethel notes how today’s lawmakers, who once supported peace efforts and social justice, now appear to stifle peaceful protests and reject military aid to foreign nations like Ukraine. This, she argues, reflects a contradiction in how today’s leaders manage foreign policy and domestic protests.
Public Education: A Disconnected Reality
Bethel discusses the state of public education in America, recalling how, in the past, public schools were seen as a pillar of social equity, providing opportunities for all children, regardless of background. Today, however, policies like “School Choice” have made it harder for low-income families to access quality education. Bethel expresses concern that this policy only further divides society, offering opportunities to those with the means to take advantage of them while leaving others behind.
Gun Rights and Public Safety
One of the most striking changes Bethel observes is the increasing emphasis on Second Amendment rights, even at the cost of public safety. She contrasts the safety of schools in her youth to the tragic rise in school shootings today. Bethel criticizes lawmakers who refuse to implement reasonable gun control measures, prioritizing gun ownership over the safety of children and educators.
A Complex Legacy
Bethel ends her letter by reflecting on the complexity of political legacies. She questions how the current political actions of today’s leaders align with their past values. Yearbook photos, newspaper archives, and personal records offer a reminder of the ideals that shaped their early years. As she calls on them to reconsider their positions, Bethel points out that their voting records will ultimately be judged by future generations, just as the actions of the past are scrutinized today.
Bethel concludes by acknowledging the dissonance she feels between the political ideals of her youth and the policies embraced by today’s lawmakers. For her, this “whiplash” represents the pain of seeing the very leaders who once fought for progress now supporting regressive policies. As she calls for a return to the values of equality, justice, and sustainability, Bethel urges lawmakers to consider the long-term impact of their decisions on future generations.
Bethel’s letter serves as a poignant reminder of the shifting political landscape and the responsibility of today’s leaders to uphold the values of justice, equality, and sustainability. Her reflections highlight the importance of introspection and action in shaping a better future for all Americans.
